If you’ve ever thought about running away to a private island in the Caribbean or the South Pacific, may we suggest these closer-to-home alternatives? Whether you want the perks of a full-service resort or a rental house without a neighbor in sight, these vacations don’t require a passport, just a quick boat (or seaplane) ride.
Buck Island, Hilton Head Island, South Carolina
Just off Hilton Head where Broad Creek meets the Calibogue Sound, this 10-acre island is just a short boat ride from the Broad Creek Marina — and the transfer is on the house. Wander the island on foot via natural paths or hop in one of the provided golf carts to explore a bit further. A main house and guest house sleep up to 26, so it’s best to bring the entire crew to make the most of the pool, hot tub, crow’s nest lookout and ample deck space.
Black’s Island, Port St. Joe, Florida
Just south of Port St. Joe in Florida’s Panhandle, Black’s Island floats in St. Joseph Bay, offering prime access to Gulf Coast fishing and some of the state’s best scalloping. The seven-acre island takes its name from Samuel “Black Sam” Bellamy, often called the wealthiest pirate in history. Today, it’s home to a collection of waterfront bungalows linked by cedar boardwalks, plus a four-story clubhouse and a pool overlooking the bay. The island is about 10 minutes from the mainland by boat — so bring your own or rent one from a local outfitter. You’ll also need to stock up on groceries before you shove off. Then spend your days kayaking, snorkeling and fishing the protected waters of the bay, or simply grilling the day’s catch on your porch.
East Sister Rock, Marathon, Florida
You and seven guests can have this 1.5-acre island all to yourselves. Just a quarter mile off Marathon in the Middle Keys and a five-minutes boat ride, East Sister Rock comes with a 5,000-square-foot main house (sprawling veranda included), a 100-foot private dock, a pool, a helipad and a natural snorkeling moat. That’s right, a moat that encircles the entire island. A 21-foot Carolina Skiff and boat transfers are included in the package, and the whole place runs on wind and solar power.
Seabird Key, Marathon, Florida
Also just off the coast of Marathon, this 10-acre tropical hideaway is yours and yours alone — no bridges, no causeways and no other guests. The centerpiece is the Old Florida-style home with breezy porches on every level and a 35-foot widow’s walk made for sunset viewing. It sleeps eight, runs on solar power and comes with a 19-foot Boston Whaler for exploring. Need help planning your adventures? The island manager can help arrange a private chef, fishing guide or massage if you’d rather not lift a finger.

Sunset Key Cottages, Key West, Florida
The resort’s 40 stand-alone cottages, ranging from one to four bedrooms, are spread across a 27-acre private island near Key West — think bougainvillea-draped porches, tin roofs, full kitchens and, in some, private plunge pools. To reach the island, you’ll board a boat shuttle from Opal Key Resort & Marina, near Mallory Square, for a seven-minute ride to Sunset Key. Spend your days on the white-sand beach or at the zero-entry pool or easily hop over to Duval Street via the boat shuttle whenever you’re craving a little Key West buzz.
Little Palm Island, Little Torch Key, Florida
Near the Lower Florida Keys, Little Palm Island is a private island resort accessible only by boat or seaplane. The adults-only property has 30 thatched-roof bungalow suites spread across the four-acre island, where you’ll trade TVs for outdoor showers, ocean views and, in some suites, outdoor copper soaking tubs. Barefoot luxury is the theme here — it’s the only hotel in the South with three Michelin Keys. But so is privacy: guests must be 18 or older and resort capacity tops out at just 60.
READ MORE: 6 new Florida hotels worth planning your next trip around
READ MORE: Get to know South Carolina’s charming Hammock Coast

